Case Study
Redesign of Estero Parkway
Flyover
-
Steel
box girder redesign in place of cast-in place concrete box
-
Linear static
modelling using beam and shell elements
-
Significant cost
savings made
|
Photo: ZEP
Construction |
Finley
Engineering Group, Inc. (FINLEY) used LUSAS Bridge for
its engineering redesign of the Estero Parkway Flyover in Fort
Myers, Florida, for the contractor, ZEP Construction. In doing so,
FINLEY’s four-steel box girder design produced significant
savings in construction costs over an initially proposed
cast-in-place concrete box girder design. As the result of the
engineering redesign done using LUSAS and cost-effectiveness
measures taken by Zep Construction, $2.94 million will be passed
to the project’s owner, Lee County, Florida, as a value
engineering credit.
Overview
The Estero Parkway Flyover is 561 feet
long, with spans of 340 and 221 feet, and approximately 116 feet wide.
It extends Estero Parkway over Interstate 75, connecting with Ben
Hill Griffin Parkway, which then meets with Corkscrew Road to the
southeast of the city.
FINLEY’s redesign replaces previously
proposed
twin, cast-in-place concrete box girders with a single, four-steel box
girder design. This redesigned solution provides significant savings with the
elimination of a large falsework support system, reduced construction
time, reduced foundation design requirements and simplified
construction. By using shallower steel girders, shallower approach
grades can be used, saving fill and construction time. It also means
that the contractor can erect the bridge in longer sections meaning
fewer obstructions in the roadway.
The new design uses a staged temporary
tower support scheme to optimize the efficiency of the steel section
which allowed the steel bridge solution to be more attractive against
a cast-in-place concrete one. The redesign also enhances overall
project safety with the elimination of the falsework system over the
interstate and reduces the risks associated with a constrained traffic
pattern through the falsework system.
Bridge Construction
Each
curved steel box girder comprises webs of 1" thick plate and top
and bottom flange thicknesses of 1-1/4" plate. Internal X bracing
formed of WT and L sections is used in conjunction with diagonal top
flange bracing of WT sections to stiffen the girders. At supports,
1-1/4" thick internal diaphragms with access holes are used with
end diaphragms of 1/2" thick web and flange plates connect
adjacent girders.
Modelling and analysis
In all, 15,000 quadrilateral thick
shell elements modeled the 4 box girders and stiffeners in the bridge
structure. Customized displays of assigned geometric attributes such
as steel plate sizes were produced by visualizing each thickness in
turn - especially useful for checking that the correct thickness
assignments were made. This in conjunction with the LUSAS groups
facility, which permits easy definition and isolation of each
sub-element of the model for display and model building purposes, and
the fleshing facility, which helps ensure the correct orientation of
standard section sizes is obtained, helped FINLEY to build the model
in a very straightforward manner. Pinned supports including the
temporary supports beneath the longest span were assigned to the model
and a linear static analysis was carried out. From the LUSAS analysis
overall girder displacements and stresses in the bracing struts and
girder plates were obtained for the applied loading.
|
Resultant
displacements from deck pour loading |
|
|
Typical absolute
stresses in girder 1 from deck pour |
Colour coded axial
stresses in girder 1 bracing struts from deck pour |
|
Photo: ZEP
Construction |
Benefits obtained
The
project was completed in September 2009. Craig Finley, president of FINLEY said:
"We see this as a great example of what can happen with value
engineering when the owner, contractor and engineer come together to
create a design that takes the contractor’s strengths into account
and that utilizes the best material and the most appropriate software
for the challenges of the project." He added: "In this case,
the redesign from concrete to steel had an overall positive effect on
the cost, schedule, and efficiency of the bridge, and the use of LUSAS
helped us meet our design deadline and to prove an alternative bridge
design that will ultimately save the client a great deal of money in
construction costs.". This view was echoed by Donald Deberry,
P.E., public works operations manager for Lee County. "We are
obviously pleased," he said. "We always appreciate working
with engineers and contractors who are willing to take a second look
at projects and find ways to give the public more bang for their
buck."
|
|
"The use of LUSAS helped us meet
our design deadline and to prove an alternative bridge design that
will ultimately save the client a great deal of money in construction
costs."
Craig Finley, President,
Finley Engineering Group, Inc.
Find out more
Other LUSAS Bridge case studies:
|
|
Software Information
|